原帖由 小妖 於 2011-3-2309:09 PM 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
雙腳剷波點都要俾紅牌
really 2 foot?
only his right leg was to the ball,
his left was at his buttocks
He even did not stretch his left leg when he hit the ball and ground.
Look at the 6th second of the video plz.
Both players 'fly' to the ball, even Holden.
Yet one is injured, and the other one get a red card.
If you define Evans did a 2 foot, so did Holden then. I dont see a significant difference between what they did.
Yet the right leg of evans hit the ball, while that of Holden did not and hit the grass. And he used his lower leg to hit the ball. So wt happened? Holden used his left lower leg to hit the ball and the studs of the right shoes of Evans.
What would happen if Evans lower his studs? With such collision I guess his right ankle would be ruined, probably.
My verdict is both are reckless to make such a tackle. Evans could probably have been out 6 months in engaging such a tackle. Red card? Does a single leg stud-high tackle aimed at ball deserves that? Your say. But I cant agree.
[ 本帖最後由 Gianni Rivera 於 2011-3-2310:38 PM 編輯 ]
原帖由 Gianni Rivera 於 2011-3-2310:02 PM 發表 http://hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
0:30 :icon101:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7Rnt5C2qaQ&feature=related
Tell me, WHERE IS THE CONTACT? :icon101:
咩都唔使講
剩係鞋底去都夠紅LA
原帖由 francesco_totti 於 2011-3-2311:34 PM 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
咩都唔使講
剩係鞋底去都夠紅LA
係囉 :icon101:
原帖由 奇連士文再生 於 2011-3-2311:12 PM 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
Tell me, WHERE IS THE CONTACT? :icon101:
0:30 refers to the previous video :icon101:
0:28 actually.
[ 本帖最後由 Gianni Rivera 於 2011-3-2412:36 AM 編輯 ]
OK, so 鞋底去 既TACKLE = RED
FINE.
原帖由 奇連士文再生 於 2011-3-2311:12 PM 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
Tell me, WHERE IS THE CONTACT? :icon101:
The point of the 2nd video is not the contact
It is the action of sol campbell
Flying tackle, 2 feet, studs up,
The croatian player is ruined if he did not jump.
Would it be a red if he had not jump? By your standard, yes.
[ 本帖最後由 Gianni Rivera 於 2011-3-2412:43 AM 編輯 ]
原帖由 Gianni Rivera 於 2011-3-2412:35 AM 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
0:30 refers to the previous video :icon101:
0:28 actually.
你拎其他黎講無意思
鞋底行先仲要中人一定紅，其他差唔多類型的TACKLE無紅到可能係錯判
無理由因為其他錯判，所以呢個TACKLE唔使俾紅
我覺得荷頓個勢同動作都唔好得去邊
而家好明顯利益歸於倒地者:icon101:
原帖由 AC米仔 於 2011-3-2400:57 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
我覺得荷頓個勢同動作都唔好得去邊
而家好明顯利益歸於倒地者:icon101:
agree
大家都係見到個波就成個人去哂
不過 Evans 斷正 studs up 所以 :icon126:
更唔好彩 ge 係 Holden 重傷要長抖
不過果下如果講話係茅波都真係未必係...
只係 tackle 落去大家唔錫身咁 lor
停 3 場已經算重手左...
雖然 Evans 個底唔係話好好...
不過如果因為依下話佢係茅柴就有點兒那個 :(
原帖由 TZZero 於 2011-3-2401:01 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
agree
大家都係見到個波就成個人去哂
不過 Evans 斷正 studs up 所以 :icon126:
更唔好彩 ge 係 Holden 重傷要長抖
不過果下如果講話係茅波都真係未必係...
只係 tackle 落去大家唔錫身咁 lor
停 3 場已經算重手 ...
強尼反應慢d
而家畀人話既應該係荷頓,倒地既會係佢自己:icon101:
如果咁都唔紅既話真係成隊人都收晒山
我係高登?
:icon082:
Evans told BBC Sport: "I just said I was sorry, and that I didn't mean to go in and hurt him."
The Northern Ireland defender added: "At the time I did think I'd gone in for a fair challenge and I'd won the ball.
"But looking back on it when I went straight off the pitch and into the changing rooms and saw the tackle again, I realised it wasn't a good tackle from myself - and my concerns were immediately with Stuart.
"Bolton's doctor was keeping me informed, and gave me a call on Monday.
"It was disappointing to hear the news, I just rang him straight away to apologise."
原帖由 TZZero 於 2011-3-2401:01 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
agree
大家都係見到個波就成個人去哂
不過 Evans 斷正 studs up 所以 :icon126:
更唔好彩 ge 係 Holden 重傷要長抖
不過果下如果講話係茅波都真係未必係...
只係 tackle 落去大家唔錫身咁 lor
停 3 場已經算重手 ...
直紅停3場又叫"算重手" ,咁依你計應該點判?
Soft football nowadays
I enjoy watching Gentile marking Maradona
Football is not for ballerinas
深夜睇人踢斷腳真係一種享受
這已是賀頓在短短的一年時間里，連續兩次被對手鏟斷腳了。去年2月底，在美國對陣荷蘭隊的一場熱身賽中，賀頓被荷蘭防守中場尼祖迪莊粗暴鏟斷右腿，導致腓骨骨折。
:o
原帖由 AC米仔 於 2011-3-2412:57 AM 發表 http://www.hkcmforum.com/images/common/back.gif
我覺得荷頓個勢同動作都唔好得去邊
而家好明顯利益歸於倒地者:icon101:
根本係大家一齊雙腳向波飛落去 :icon101:
如果呢下係 Evans 中招曼迷嘈實好多人幫 Holden 講o野 :icon101:
[ 本帖最後由 捷禾@Ajax 於 2011-3-2501:46 AM 編輯 ]