from外國FM網---Physical是否太重要?

2076

第一部分
I took a lowly Conference side Tamworth, renamed it to Athletes Athletics, changed every player's CA/PA to 1 and set all relevant attributes to 20 in the pregame editor. So, a typical athlete looks like this (GK's look a bit better for some reason - they have 7's instead of 5's).
Then I started the game and went on holiday.

Test 1. Conference with Diablo
1st C Athletes 42 41 1 0 180 6 +174 124
FA Trophy winners, FA Cup winners.

I started with diablo only because I was unsure about the actual strength of the team...

Test 2. Conference with default 4-4-2 Defensive
1st C Athletes 42 42 0 0 195 2 +193 126
FA Trophy winners, FA Cup winners.

...but even with a default formation they've crushed everyone on their way (including Arsenal and Everton in FA Cup).

Too easy so far. Remember that they have ability of 1 after all. In the next test I plan to move the team to the Premiership. It would be fun if the team of utterly talentless footballers (who are extremely gifted athletes though) could do well at the highest level...

Test 3. Premiership, default tactics
1st C Athletes 38 32 3 3 89 18 +71 99
2nd Arsenal 38 24 7 7 82 36 +46 79

League Cup winners
FA Cup Semis (lost to Man City on pens after 0:0, their GK got a 10)

Our 3 league defeats came from Man Utd 0:1, Chelsea 0:1 and Newcastle 1:2, all away.

第二部分
I've made another test - set every non-physical attribute to 1. So the typical athlete now looks like this. (Don't ask why do technical attributes appear as 5's - they were all 1's in the editor).

As a result, we finished 3rd in the Premiership.

1st C Chelsea 38 14 2 3 40 12 10 8 1 20 8 +40 82
2nd Man Utd 38 15 2 2 39 11 8 8 3 28 19 +37 79
3rd Athletes 38 12 6 1 30 5 9 6 4 20 6 +39 75

Also reached the final of the FA Cup. Not bad I suppose.

第三部分
So, I've done the test beffrey suggested, only leaving Acceleration, Pace, Jumping, Stamina and Natural Fitness as 20. So, the players now have lost their Balance, Agility and Strength as well.

Results are much worse this time:

16th Charlton 38 5 8 6 21 26 2 5 12 13 29 -21 34
17th Athletes 38 6 6 7 21 17 3 1 15 12 40 -24 34
18th R Bolton 38 4 6 9 21 34 1 11 7 15 33 -31 32

However, still not bad enough to get us relegated.

Also reached the FA Cup Final.

What is really weird, is that this time we've received incredible 16 red and 90 yellow cards (compare it to 1 and 16 in the previous test)! Probably agility has something to do with this.

據聞FM05會著手改善呢個問題


附加:
Saw this thread upped, so I thought I would try the opposite test. I took Northwich Vics and gave all of their players 200 CA/PA, and 20's for all technical stats, and 1's for physical. I'm using the default 4-4-2 defensive tactic on holiday.

So far:
Izmirspor 0-7
G. Antepspor 0-7
Bursaspor 0-6
Kilmarnock 0-9
Burnley 0-11
Nottingham Forest 0-6
Aldershot 0-6
Scarborough 1-10

Finished the season:

22nd Northwich Vics 42 0 1 41 4 219 -215 1

Biggest defeat was 12-0 to Halifax away

Hakkinen

做咩搵NORTHWICH VICS 黎搞
不過CM 所謂妖人既PHYSICAL 都係勁得恐怖