假如.....

HackerWong

成日想心思思開個History討論topic...
今日試下開個Alternate History試作仔...試下反應:

1939年5月3日,Stalin炒左佢既Commissar for Foreign Affairs,猶太人Maxim Litvinov,而Maxim Litvinov之前一直從事d反法西斯主義既政策ge..
係8月28日,Stalin同Hitler係Moscow簽左Nazi-Soviet Pact...話2個國家唔會互抽咁話wor..
之後仲夾份搞掂Poland添
但之後Hitler眼紅Balkans既地,以及更多ge原因(其中一個係因為Hitler on_ )而發動左Operation Barbarossa,想搞掂Soviet Union..
但係失敗左,武運仲一直頹落去添...

d Historian話:
Britain挫左Nazi Germany既銳氣同show比人睇German唔係無堅不催
而Soviet Union就話比全世界人知German並唔係打唔贏ge...

o拿...
What if Nazi Germany無打Soviet Union...仲保持住一種互相利用既關係...
World War 2既形勢會有咩改變?
而正義必勝既結局又會唔會有改變??

[ Last edited by HackerWong on 11-9-2005 at 05:27 PM ]

橙色力量

Originally posted by HackerWong at 2005-9-11 07:16 AM:
o拿...
What if Nazi Germany無打Soviet Union...仲保持住一種互相利用既關係...
World War 2既形勢會有咩改變?
而正義必勝既結局又會唔會有改變??

老希不發動「反猶太斯拉夫布爾什維克聖戰」，就不是老希矣。

不過如果......

The New Delhi Conference         
Point of Divergence:  Hitler dies in a car crash in February of 1941.        
               
       
Flash forward to 1956 New Delhi:                
Part 1:  The Racket-buster Goes to the Gangsters

...

http://www.geocities.com/misterralls/NewDelhiCon1.html

歐石南

禁咪調轉
阿史譚....唔係係史太林打q希比...係希特拉

stephenlion

history 入面無WHAT IF...


係喇
我係黎生事既

HackerWong

Originally posted by stephenlion at 11-9-05 03:00 PM:
history 入面無WHAT IF...


係喇
我係黎生事既

HackerWong

Communism同Fascism係天敵..
但假如Soviet Union同Nazi Germany推遲左互毆eg時間...會點??

[ Last edited by HackerWong on 11-9-2005 at 05:46 PM ]

橙色力量

Originally posted by stephenlion at 2005-9-11 03:00 PM:
history 入面無WHAT IF...


係喇
我係黎生事既

Alternative History 入面無「無WHAT IF」...

joekjen

Originally posted by HackerWong at 2005-9-11 03:11 PM:
Communism同Fascism係天敵..
但假如Soviet Union同Nazi Germany推遲左互毆eg時間...會點??

[ Last edited by HackerWong on 11-9-2005 at 05:46 PM ]

可以老希會加強支援非洲,

5號豹式果樣會唔同左囉

截拳道小子

西面又擴張唔到
南面打黎都無咩大作用
唔打都無咩好做啦


就算捱多few years~
美國都屈機勝ga la
對result no major effect
大不了意大利無咁頹掛


老吹

stephenlion

Originally posted by 橙色力量 at 2005-9-11 17:24:


Alternative History 入面無「無WHAT IF」...

HackerWong

Originally posted by 截拳道小子 at 11-9-05 06:14 PM:
西面又擴張唔到
南面打黎都無咩大作用
唔打都無咩好做啦


就算捱多few years~
美國都屈機勝ga la
對result no major effect
大不了意大利無咁頹掛


老吹

但係如果control到Europe同非洲...
我有d懷疑老美屈唔屈到機

HackerWong

Originally posted by stephenlion at 11-9-05 06:27 PM:

橙色力量

Originally posted by HackerWong at 2005-9-11 06:28 PM:


但係如果control到Europe同非洲...
我有d懷疑老美屈唔屈到機

A-Bomb+B-36, then H-Bomb on the way...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-36

HackerWong

Originally posted by 橙色力量 at 11-9-05 06:31 PM:


A-Bomb+B-36, then H-Bomb on the way...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-36

唔好咁老定
Man power + raw materials..邪惡帝國未必無機同老美鬥快

joekjen

Originally posted by 截拳道小子 at 2005-9-11 06:14 PM:
西面又擴張唔到
南面打黎都無咩大作用
唔打都無咩好做啦


就算捱多few years~
美國都屈機勝ga la
對result no major effect
大不了意大利無咁頹掛


老吹

意大利可能會仲頹,非洲都比德國霸左

joekjen

對太平洋會有咩野影響?

如果非洲,中東真係被德國食左
英國可能只好放棄南亞,全力防守本土

橙色力量

Originally posted by stephenlion at 2005-9-11 06:27 PM:

煩請獅子另開「歷史決定論」帖子。

[ Last edited by 橙色力量 on 11-9-2005 at 06:42 PM ]

HackerWong

Originally posted by joekjen at 11-9-05 06:37 PM:
對太平洋會有咩野影響?

如果非洲,中東真係被德國食左
英國可能只好放棄南亞,全力防守本土

守乜鬼ar..
如果Nazi Germany食左非洲,中東..+ Europe
鬥resources....Britain死_硬

除非Commonwealth救亡la...

[ Last edited by HackerWong on 11-9-2005 at 06:44 PM ]

橙色力量

Originally posted by joekjen at 2005-9-11 06:37 PM:
對太平洋會有咩野影響?

如果非洲,中東真係被德國食左
英國可能只好放棄南亞,全力防守本土

日本可能死得仲快，假設德國冇向美國宣戰......

joekjen

Originally posted by HackerWong at 2005-9-11 06:42 PM:


守乜鬼ar..
如果Nazi Germany食左非洲,中東..+ Europe
鬥resources....Britain死_硬

除非Commonwealth救亡la...

[ Last edited by HackerWong on 11-9-2005 at 06:44 PM ]

咁要睇下德國幾時可以復產中東既油田