英文勁既人試下解吧!

cmh_2002

Teacher : What's wrong with this sentence? "Ann didn't go to the libary as she had had a birthday."

Student : If the sentence which had had had had had had, it would have been correct.

6 個 "HAD" 應該點解?



given that student's sentence is correct

siuming

原帖由 cmh_2002 於 2005-12-21  07:58 PM 發表
Teacher : What's wrong with this sentence? "Ann didn't go to the libary as she had had a birthday."

Student : If the sentence which had had had had had had, it would have been correct. ...

Ann didnt go to the library as she had had had had had had a birthday.
完全唔明

肥仔麟

痴線 , 呢度有冇人UE A ?

傑夫仔

原帖由 cmh_2002 於 2005-12-21  07:58 PM 發表
Teacher : What's wrong with this sentence? "Ann didn't go to the libary as she had had a birthday."

Student : If the sentence which had had had had had had, it would have been correct. ...

咁？

Hala Madrid

Teacher : What's wrong with this sentence? "Ann didn't go to the libary as she 'had had' a birthday."

Student : If the sentence which had 'had had' had had 'had', it would have been correct.

had = past tense of 'have'
'had had' = incorrect usage in teacher's statement
had had = past perfect tense of 'have'
'had' = the should-be correct usage


???

沙9

口吃

Manu super fans

原帖由 Hala Madrid 於 2005-12-25  02:38 PM 發表
Teacher : What's wrong with this sentence? "Ann didn't go to the libary as she 'had had' a birthday."

Student : If the sentence which had [colo ...

明白了

納比

我諗起我班ＦＲＤ成日玩埋既無聊野：

Ａ：你唔知咩？
Ｂ：你唔知我唔知咩？
Ａ：你唔知我唔知你唔知咩？
Ｂ：你唔知我唔知你唔知我唔知咩？
．．．．

kalok914

黃子華
我請你請我食飯